Rote Learning Vs Meaningful Learning

more_vert

Rote learning can be defined as a memorization technique based on repeating the material again and again until you get through with it and begin to memorize. The idea behind the rote learning is that one will be able to quickly recall the meaning of the material the more one repeats it. Some of the alternatives to rote learning include meaningful learning, associative learning, and active learning. Rote learning is generally based on only repeating the topics and not the clear understanding of the topics. Rote learning methods are generally used when quick memorization is required, such as learning one's lines in a play or memorizing a telephone number, also some students opt for rote learning instead of meaningful learning method with the clear understanding of the subject. Rote learning is widely used in the mastery of foundational knowledge.

Meaningful learning, on the other hand, refers to the concept of learning the subject or topic with the clear understanding of all the related facts. When learned by meaningfully, the learned knowledge is fully understood by the individual and he also knows well how that specific fact relates to other stored facts in his brain. For understanding this concept, it is good to contrast meaningful learning with the much less desirable, rote learning. Rote learning is the method where you memorize something without full understanding and you don't know how the new information relates to your other stored knowledge.

What is Rote Learning?

Rote learning as discussed earlier involves verbatim memorization. Remembering a particular phone number, dates and names are examples of rote learning. Repeating material, again and again, helps a learner recall it exactly as it was presented. Stuff that doesn't relate to anything else is learned by rote learning method. Meaningful learning, on the other hand, is tied and related and integrated to previous learning. Needless to say, meaningful learning is generally more powerful and interesting. Rote learning does not give you any meaningful learning experience and you are not sure of utilizing that information for some practical use. Rote learning is like singing along with a song playing on your I-pod or radio and after a couple of times, you start to pick up interesting lines and slowly you realize that you have learned the whole song. Some other examples of rote learning may include:

  • School topics where rote learning is frequently used include phonics in reading and especially cramming at the time of the test.
  • The periodic table in chemistry, you cannot have a reason for every element placement in the table, hence most of the time students end up cramming the position of elements in the periodic table.
  • Multiplication tables in mathematics, that most of the students learn by rote methodology.
  • Anatomy in medicine, there is no reason for the general human anatomy and you cannot find any other memorization technique for the anatomy. Hence only technique left is by the rote method.
  • Cases or statutes in law,

You cannot find a reason for every small formula that you have to use in a subject. For example, a simple formula for momentum is p=mv which has a long two-page derivation. If a student goes on learning all these derivations he would not be in a state to learn anything else for his examination.

Rote learning eschews comprehension, so by itself, it is an ineffective tool in mastering any complex subject at an advanced level. Though, it may be a good tool for just memorizing something or the other, but not if you need to utilize that information for some practical purpose. For instance, one illustration of Rote learning can be observed in preparing quickly for exams, a technique which may be colloquially referred to as "cramming". Cramming may sometimes help you score decent grades sometimes but not every time. Also, it is a fact that cramming won’t help you out in long run. Every topic that is being taught has its bigger significance somewhere in the future, and at that time you end up with no information left in your brain.

Talking about studies, rote learning finds some usefulness by students in math and science. Rote methods are often used, for example, to memorize formulas or tables. There is greater understanding if students commit a formula to memory through exercises that use the formula rather than through rote repetition of the formula. But most of the students find it quite useful to just cram the periodic table position, formula or tables in mathematics as an understanding of these topics may involve a lot of explanation and derivation work, that may become really complex and cumbersome for a student. Standards always recommend that students derive formulas themselves to achieve the best understanding and utilization. Nothing can faster than rote learning if a formula is to be learned quickly for an important test and rote methods can be helpful for committing an understood fact to memory.

However, it is often observed that students who learn with understanding are really clear with all the facts and are conveniently able to transfer their knowledge to tasks requiring problem-solving with greater success than those who learn only by rote.

What is Meaningful Learning?

Meaningful learning is very important to form the student point of view. Meaningful learning in today's competitive world holds the key to success. These days it is not just your grades that matter to be successful; it is something more than that. These days in the interview you are tested on your practical skills and practical knowledge before looking at your result cards. Once you clear your interview level based on knowledge and facts, then only you are asked about your grades and qualifications. Hence proper knowledge is a must for anyone to be successful these days. Developing a capability of 'learning to learn' and higher-level thinking skills is a life-long practice and must be honed on a continual basis.

Meaningful learning helps us a lot, in fact, our brain is designed for meaningful learning only. Our brain works in an associative way and our memory serves us in a chained structure. Existing knowledge acts as a mental block for new learning to occur. Once we learned something by the meaningful method with full clarity, we are able to relate that knowledge with every relevant piece of information about that topic in our brain and possess a confidence of utilizing that information properly in our profession also. People displaying memory deftness often contend that by establishing a visual relationship between seemingly disconnected or unrelated objects or numerals, their retention is enhanced. Hence it would not be wrong to say that we do learn a lot by the process of watching something happen in practical rather than just cramming it theoretically. Some suggestions on how to ensure meaningful learning:

  • Make sure what you learn is in your proximal zone.
  • Emphasise more on the application rather than just learning.
  • Make sure you have a proper reason for everything that you are learning.
  • If there is any doubt, ask your teacher how some new knowledge is related to other course material.
  • Have a study partner ask you questions that require the recall of related material.
  • Try to make some effective memorisation points to remember the things that you have learned.
  • Strictly avoid cramming as far as possible, even for some basic formulas that you may find easy to just cram.
  • Make a figure that illustrates what you should know about a specific topic and its related material.
  • Do not mix up the things by picking up multiple topics at the same time. You may be good at multi-tasking but that won’t work in the case of learning.

The human mind is generally very good at meaningful learning compared to rote learning. It is worth noting that computers are good at replicating people aren't. So, if you are teaching facts it is very obvious that the repetition is a part of the program. If you choose to teach meaningful material then you will need a different strategy for effective teaching. The meaningful material cannot be learned immediately. Meaningful learning requires clarification of all the facts and doubts related to the topic. Once a concept or principle is learned it needs to be strengthened. That comes with practising, remember practice, not cramming. Strengthening involves relating the material to other ideas some of those already in your mind, it also involves rewording; it involves stretching an idea to see how they connect. This strengthening process increases the new material's distinctness; it creates new dimensions and prevents the material from becoming absorbed by what was previously known, although the mind is in a state to relate this newly gained information with the previous information relating to the topic. This distinctness will make the material retrievable and applicable to new circumstances.

Differences Between Rote Learning and Meaningful Learning

Educational theorists suggest a distinction between meaningful learning and rote learning. Rote learning is most commonly emphasized in primary and secondary educational settings, and consists of simple memorization of information or the topics, without concern for relationships among concepts, and the basic idea is just to get decent grades in the exams. However, in contrast, meaningful learning results from linking new information to relevant, pre-existing concepts that were learned either in previous lecture, class or year. The most important factor for learning is what the learners already know, and how effectively he can relate the new information with the pre-existing information about the same topic.

Rote learning involves learning by repetition and meaningful learning involves a review of the facts with clarification. Both repetition and review are important to the teaching and learning process. But it is the duty of the teacher to make sure to use the method that is most appropriate for particular material otherwise they will be fooling themselves and their students. It is a fact that something’s does need in cramming but there should be a proper limit. Do not go on cramming all the topics, otherwise, this may lead to a lot of confusion and students may sometimes end up blank at the time of examination.

The meaningful learning technique involves utilizing one’s own, God-gifted, resources optimally, understanding the natural associative property of our learning mechanism and adopting new ways to read, write, learn and speak, while consciously trying to break old habits of resorting to linear, text-oriented, rote learning. On the other hand rote memorization is simply the storage of data in your brain.  It does not require any understanding of the data or facts being stored.  Mastering of concepts is a more complex thought process that uses the facts to illustrate how things actually work in practical application.  A lot of students know the facts but don’t understand the concepts, and this is the danger in over-reliance on rote memorization.

Conclusion
Rote memorization is a means to an end, there is no replacement for effecting learning techniques. It is nit that rote learning is a total waste, but there should be a limit and reason. The rote method should only be used in at selected levels and cases only. For example, memorizing the Times Tables is a perfect example of a useful application of rote memorization, but the clear understanding of the concepts of multiplication is also very important, simple memorization of the times tables is not going to get one very far in real life.  Parents and educators need to be wary of situations in which a child may have memorized a bunch of information that he/she doesn’t actually understand. It would be really helpful for students in the long run if teachers and trainers lay more emphasis on the meaningful learning techniques and try to keep away cramming and rote learning methods.